Dave's Take On Microlending

Brian wants to know what Dave thinks about peer-to-peer lending. He's interested in investing in individual loans as an investment strategy. Dave thinks it's stupid.

QUESTION: Brian in Fresno wants to know what Dave thinks about peer-to-peer lending. He’s interested in investing in individual loans as an investment strategy. Dave thinks it’s stupid.

ANSWER: As a small investment strategy, it’s stupid, because these are loans that are not collateralized. They’re not checked out. Would you loan your friend money without checking him out because he needed $50? Why does a guy need $50?

There’s a social justice aspect to it that you’re helping somebody and that kind of thing. I prefer charitable giving to lending. If you’re going to help somebody, let’s just help them. Why put them into debt? It’s kind of a vogue concept. It’s kind of a faddish thing. Everybody’s yacking about it—kind of like the microlending in third-world countries. Is that helping or hurting? Certainly anytime we can help people who are hurting and take some of their stress off, that’s never a bad thing from a nobility standpoint. As an investment, no, it doesn’t make any sense at all, and is it the best way to really help someone? I personally would rather give someone money than loan them money. To me it doesn’t feel like it does much except kind of make people feel good. Did they really get a lift out of it? Was their life really changed? If $50 changes your life, I’d rather give it to you. I really would.

The motivation behind this or microlending on the third-world country level or that type of thing is very noble. I appreciate that. But since I don’t believe debt is a positive thing—since I believe it’s a curse—it would be really hypocritical for me turn around and put people into debt that I say I’m trying to help. From the standpoint that I take, it would be unethical. I can’t impugn that on someone else, but if you don’t believe debt’s a good thing and you go around putting people in debt in the name of helping them, it’s inconsistent.

Jump-Start Your Goals!

Jump-Start Your Goals!

Get our 8-Day JUMP START series and weekly newsletter that are packed with articles and tools to help you win with money.

Learn to Beat Debt

Take Control of Your Money!

The best way to get out of debt and take control of your money is to make a plan! Financial Peace University is that plan!

Find a Class

Thank You!

Your 8-Day Jump Start is on its way to !